TCCoA Forums banner

1 - 20 of 24 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
203 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
I did a search, but didn't get a clear sense of the best LCA replacement to use (MOOG, TRW, Motorcraft, other?). UCAs done about 2 months ago. Car has only 72K (I'm the original owner), but lower ball joints are starting to look funky.
What do you guys recommend? Thanks.
 

·
Super Moderator
1997 Thunderbird 4.6, 1998 Mark VIII LSC
Joined
·
9,576 Posts
As far as I know, Motorcraft is TRW (correct me if I'm wrong). But yes, Moog or Motorcraft is the way to go.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
12,676 Posts
As far as I know, Motorcraft is TRW (correct me if I'm wrong). But yes, Moog or Motorcraft is the way to go.
Yes, Motorcraft is TRW. They were the OEM contractor that built many suspension components for Ford.

So, yea as stated above go TRW or Moog.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
510 Posts
I bought moog from rockauto and they say TRW on them. These do not have grease ports though. I bought moog because I thought they would have them.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,062 Posts
I bought moog from rockauto and they say TRW on them. These do not have grease ports though. I bought moog because I thought they would have them.
Moog owns TRW and have stock. Lower Control Arms I prefer the TRW's. Do you know the part numbers sent? You might have gotten a bonus and gotten SC lowers.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
12,676 Posts
TRW and Federal-Mogul, aka Moog, are not the same company. Moog does not own TRW Automotive.

You can read a list of Federal-Mogul brands HERE.

If you ordered Moog and got TRW there was a switch made in your order.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
12,676 Posts
I stand corrected (sort of). It's Federal-Mogul that purchased "nearly all of TRW Inc.'s replacement auto parts business" not Moog which is a division of Federal-Mogul. Provided this deal went through Federal-Mogul would own that division and TRW would still stands on it's own independent of Federal-Mogul.

It's my understanding that the acquisition would have resulted in a name change for that division from TRW to MOOG. Either way they're good products regardless of which name they bear.

http://www.nytimes.com/1992/08/25/business/company-news-federal-mogul-to-buy-trw-auto-parts-business.html
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
59 Posts
Besides Ford OEM parts.....only the TRW 10771 and 10772 LCA's have been verified to have the correct inner pivot bushings for a SC. Not getting easier to find them though. Moog lists no difference in PN for the NA or SC LCA's....BUT...the SC specific arms have inner pivot bushings with almost twice the spring rate (stiffness) as the NA version. At least they did when they were made for/by Ford.
 

·
Newbie
Joined
·
5,650 Posts
Yes, Motorcraft is TRW. They were the OEM contractor that built many suspension components for Ford.

So, yea as stated above go TRW or Moog.
There's even some shadiness there. Technically, Motorcraft is not TRW. As an example, if you go to Ford and ask for an upper control arm, you can get the Motorcraft piece or you can get the OEM TRW piece. They are not the same.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
59 Posts
No shadiness at all. TRW was the OE Supplier to Ford for many of the suspension parts used on the MN12. Ford does not make 100% of all the parts on any car they make. Just like Tokico supplied the shocks....TRW made suspension parts.

MOOG never has been an OE Supplier to the auto industry. They never had the requisite quality to qualify.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,170 Posts
There's even some shadiness there. Technically, Motorcraft is not TRW. As an example, if you go to Ford and ask for an upper control arm, you can get the Motorcraft piece or you can get the OEM TRW piece. They are not the same.
Yes, the motorcraft UCA is greasable, and cost 1/2 what the Ford one cost. It seems like a good unit but it has a layer of light surface rust on it now. The 14 yo original cleaned up black shiny new. Generally though you can trust Motorcraft to source from a good supplier. The dealer would have no problem replacing your arm with the Motorcraft one under warranty though. They both pass Fords quality standard.

The rear Motorcraft white shocks I replaced were definately made by Monroe/Tenneco. The new sensatracs had very similar markings and varied by a date code. The welds and shock looked exact except for color and graphics. After 4 years they needed replacement...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,170 Posts
No shadiness at all. TRW was the OE Supplier to Ford for many of the suspension parts used on the MN12. Ford does not make 100% of all the parts on any car they make. Just like Tokico supplied the shocks....TRW made suspension parts.

MOOG never has been an OE Supplier to the auto industry. They never had the requisite quality to qualify.
Well the Moog (probably reboxed TRW) sway bar links appear identical to the Ford units. They even have the same plastic shipping cones on the ends. From what I understand MOOG is TRWs aftermarket now, a manager in advance auto told me that. Overnight all their TRW stuff became MOOG.

Also, TRW may be using MOOGs factory to manufacture parts for them, and rebadge it TRW with their quality spec.

Also, brands today source things globally and just slap their name on it. I've bought a TRW arm made in Canada, and at another time it was made in the US and it had slightly different markings. Usually there are two suppliers in the Auto industry in case there are issues. Like with the shocks, Ford may be using Tenneco and Tokico for their needs.

Bottom line is buying from an OEM supplier will give you the best in quality.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,164 Posts
Are the Motorcraft control arms no longer available? I went to the Motorcraft website and did a search for all Motorcraft parts available for a 1997 Thunderbird w/4.6 liter motor - the only suspension pieces listed were control arm bushings and sway-bar end-links.

Dennis
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,170 Posts
Are the Motorcraft control arms no longer available? I went to the Motorcraft website and did a search for all Motorcraft parts available for a 1997 Thunderbird w/4.6 liter motor - the only suspension pieces listed were control arm bushings and sway-bar end-links.

Dennis
Ask jon in the ford parts counter. He recently quoted about $44 for them.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
59 Posts
Apperances can be deceiving.

As far as the poster that noted the Motorcraft front UCA had greaseable balljoints....not according to the original design they don't. They are teflon lined ball joints for low friction by original design and are not greaseable. If you get a greasable joint then it is metal on metal inside and not of a low friction design. Same for the lower ball joint....low friction design...not greasable. Tokico was the ONLY supplier of the ARC shocks for the SC and select XR7's. Have no idea who made the conventional shocks for MN12's.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
7,062 Posts
Apperances can be deceiving.

As far as the poster that noted the Motorcraft front UCA had greaseable balljoints....not according to the original design they don't. They are teflon lined ball joints for low friction by original design and are not greaseable. If you get a greasable joint then it is metal on metal inside and not of a low friction design. Same for the lower ball joint....low friction design...not greasable. Tokico was the ONLY supplier of the ARC shocks for the SC and select XR7's. Have no idea who made the conventional shocks for MN12's.
Duffy this is correct. The Motorcraft units ar different than the Ford UCA. And I find it interesting that they mentioned rust. The new TRW units I have are nice and painted black and the MOOG units (with grease fittings) rusted rather quickly.
 

·
Super Moderator
1997 Thunderbird 4.6, 1998 Mark VIII LSC
Joined
·
9,576 Posts
Are the Motorcraft control arms no longer available? I went to the Motorcraft website and did a search for all Motorcraft parts available for a 1997 Thunderbird w/4.6 liter motor - the only suspension pieces listed were control arm bushings and sway-bar end-links.

Dennis

Indeed they are; RockAuto has them for sale too, although Jon can get you one for less.
 
1 - 20 of 24 Posts
Top